Senate Maneuver Blocks Amendments to Partisan Political Map PDF Print E-mail

Senate Democrats apparently short-circuited the ability of individual senators to offer changes to the once-a-decade redrawing of state and congressional district boundaries on Sunday.

By passing three "shell" bills to the House which contained no content, the Senate likely surrendered the opportunity for members to offer up amendments or changes to the measures.

As the measures were being pushed through during a late Sunday afternoon session, Deputy Senate Republican  Leader Dale Righter (R-Mattoon) said the "shells" were being rushed through to make it easier for Democrats to adopt a final map "before anyone has got a chance to catch their breath, and look at the lines and figure out what's going on."

The Senate action came after the rushed and secretive mapmaking process drew sharp criticism at both a House hearing on Sunday and a Senate hearing on Saturday.

The Illinois Campaign for Political Reform testified Sunday it was inappropriate and inexcusable to hold such few hearings – remarks that were echoed by fellow reformers, including the League of Women Voters and Change Illinois.

The public hearings in Chicago also drew criticism from groups representing minority voters. Silvia Puente, executive director of the Latino Policy Forum told Senators Saturday that Latino voters "are being shortchanged by the proposals."

Bruce Crosby, Chairman of the Committee to Preserve Voting Rights said it was an insult for the majority to rush the map through the process.

And, Dr. Mujahid Ghazi said the Asian-American community has not been treated fairly by redistricting in the past nor by this new map.  He said their communities have been fragmented by the maps, which dilutes their votes and undermines representation of their views and interests 

The gerrymandering of districts in the metro-east area prompted the Belleville News Democrat to editorialize about "shenanigans in the rain" and said it "hacks us off" that Democrats "went around the state, pretending to listen to the people's voices at 15 'hearings.'

The three bills passed on party-line votes in the Senate (SB 1177, SB 1178 and SB 1179) contain nothing more than titles. The maneuver allows the House to add all the detail to the legislation and then send it back to the Senate for a single up or down vote with no opportunity for Senators to offer individual amendments.